| Crime |
On August 30, 2010, officers responded to a suspicious incident. When they arrived, they found Alfred McMurray dead from a gunshot wound. More than a decade later, police charged Aaron Dobbins with the crime. |
| Evidence |
Investigators collected many items of evidence including intimate swabs from the victim, a spent casing, and steering wheel swabs. |
| DNA |
The Broward County Sheriff's Office Crime Laboratory generated DNA data from the evidence items. |
| Match |
The laboratory was able to interpret some evidence data, getting the same results as TrueAllele that statistically included the defendant. The defense had alternate explanations about why the defendant’s DNA was present on those items. However, the lab reported some data or comparisons as inconclusive. |
| TrueAllele |
On the data for the three items listed above, TrueAllele statistically excluded the defendant. Additionally, the computer calculated an inclusionary match statistic of 82.1 between the victim’s intimate swabs and another person (error rate 1 in 2.34 thousand). |
| Cybergenetics |
On February 10, 2026, Cybergenetics analyst William Allan testified before a Broward County jury about the TrueAllele DNA results. |
| Outcome |
On February 12, 2026, the jury found the defendant not guilty of first degree murder. |
